Showing posts with label Racism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Racism. Show all posts

Friday, October 28, 2016

Identity is not an opinion

This is an example of an opinion I disagree with. I can post this without agreeing with it.
This post is not about opinions I disagree with, though.
Another person's identity is not something you get an "opinion" on. Yesterday I was chatting on facebook with an acquaintance* I've known for about 15 years but have rarely spoken with. He made an extremely trans-hating comment, so I asked for clarification. I mean, there's no way I could have heard it correctly. I mean, we met at a Pagan festival where he sold me a $15 Bid pen and gave me a free bottle of mead with it. He must be open minded, right? Yes, I know, overly positive and hopeful statement. Blah. Anyway, at my request for further elucidation, Magpie* reiterated his transphobia and called it "just his opinion." He repeated that statement several times and with smiley face emoticons said he hoped I wouldn't think badly of him for his “opinion."

Tuesday, November 24, 2015

Stay Open on Thanksgiving, Please!


I'm working from home on Thanksgiving, and I'll be doing it from a local coffee shop that's staying open because I live in the Boston area. This means I can't afford to rent my own apartment and have a roommate who has her family coming over for Thanksgiving. Rather than hide in my room in my pajamas afraid to be forced to eat with them if I dare walk out to pee or grab a sandwich for lunch, I'm going to a local coffee shop.

I can't get back to my hometown for Thanksgiving, and even if I did go back, my mother and grandmother have passed away. My sister goes to her husband's mother's house for holidays, so I'd drive down in the middle of the night, eat a bird at a stranger's house, and then drive home so I can get back to the office and work on Friday. My office is open Friday, but I'm working Thursday because I had an invite for post-Thanksgiving hanging outs on Friday :-)

There are a lot of companies getting flack for being open on Thanksgiving, but being open on Thanksgiving isn't necessarily a bad thing. If fat Aunt Martha drove three hours to get here and you immediately dumped a pot of coffee on her outfit, she can run to Sears for a new blouse (since nobody else's clothes are large enough for her). When you realize you forgot to buy cranberry sauce you can send one of the kids out for the cranberry sauce that comes out of a can. While they're at the store, you'll probably text them to pick up extra stuffing, some celery, and butter without salt (because you forgot that Grandpa's heart problems require a low salt meal).

All the screaming about how people shouldn't have to work on Thanksgiving and stores should be closed pisses me off. Here's some of the reasons why:

Monday, October 26, 2015

Why Do People Like Trump?

I need to stop admitting that I know someone who wants to vote for Trump. I'm tired of explaining the reasons someone might have for not seeing that a vote for Trump is a vote for hate and a vote for economic policies that benefit the rich and further screw folks without money.

Seriously, how on earth did I become the "this is why people want an asshat for president" spokesperson? I should have kept my mouth shut! But I couldn't. There are so many people who see why Trump is a bad choice and also don't understand why Trump is appealing to others. So I end up discussing it, explaining the demographic he's going for, and doing everything in my power to not lose the internet war and compare him to Hitler and Nazi Germany's rise to power by heaping hatred on certain peoples rather than actually looking at crappy economic problems that are actually the root cause. Because we all know that once you use Hitler as your example, you lose because you are too stupid to come up with any other argument.

So here are the discussion points I've raised. Please let me know if you have other points I should add to the discussion. The reason I have been agreeing to these discussions is that too many people are dismissing Trump as impossible and not realizing why he is appealing to the audience who loves him.

The Haka: Cultural Appropriation?

I've been reading a lot more about cultural appropriation because Halloween is coming. While much of it was already known, a few pieces that I hadn't considered came into play when a friend told me he wasn't wearing a grass skirt to a Hawaiian luau that was being held at an event we attended last spring. A friend just sent me this article about an American football team, the Arizona Wildcats, doing the Haka.

For folks who don't know what it is, the haka is Maori war dance. The Maori people were the folks who settled New Zealand centuries before the Europeans found their way down to that delightfully beautiful country.

The article is short and appears to make two main points about why it's a problem that the Wildcats chose to do the haka:
  1. The Wildcats did it badly. They didn't practice. They didn't learn the proper pronunciation for the words. What would have been said if the Wildcats had actually put effort into it? What if they'd bothered to learn the proper pronunciation and had practiced so that they could perform it seamlessly?
  2. The Wildcats stole the haka from the All Blacks, the New Zealand rugby team. Sure one of the first sentences specifies that the haka is a Maori dance, but the entire article focuses on the All Black's performance of the haka before rugby games while saying that Americans are making a mockery of the Maori culture.  So doesn't this mean that the Americans are appropriating a New Zealand cultural dance that had already been stolen from Maori traditions?


Here's the thing - who stole the haka? The Americans? The Europeans?  If someone in a country outside the US wore a Native American headdress because they were being the mascot from the American Football Redskins football team, would they be appropriating Native American culture or would they be copying racist American culture that was based on wildly inappropriate usage of Native American culture?

Kiwis take the All Blacks and their pre-game haka seriously. So I hope y'all understand that I'm simply curious and questioning and not insulting your love of the team. I still have my All Blacks pin!

Ideas? Thoughts?

Sunday, October 4, 2015

Waves of Feminism

I was introduced to the third wave of feminism in the early-to-mid 90s. I define feminism as the advocacy of equal rights and opportunities for everybody; regardless of sex, gender, race, ethnicity, religious background, sexual orientation, body size or type, economics, age, family status, and physical or intellectual abilities, through political, social, personal, educational, and economic means.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Feminist_Suffrage_Parade_in_New_York_City,_1912.jpeg#filelinks
First Wave Feminism, it takes money to get matching white dresses.
First wave feminism was the women's suffragist movement, a lot of which focused on getting the vote (think Margaret Sanger as well as the Pankhursts) but also focused on economics and sexuality. A large subsection of the suffragette movement was made up of middle to upper class women: Women who had the time to make matching sashes, the money to get pretty white dresses, and the education to write up and distribute flyers.

Second wave feminism is what many people think of when they think of the women's rights movement- the 1960s, the hippy movement, the push for equality with economics and culture and free love. However, it was still organized in the US by mainly white women. The equal rights movements had a decently sized divide among color lines, even as whites went down south to march for black rights, there was a distinction. While there was discussion of all races, there was a large push from middle to upper class women in the movement. There's also been rewriting of history that shows us a focus on these women in much the same way the new Stonewall movie is "forgetting" that Drag Queens and people of color were so heavily involved in that historical time.

http://www.joyridecoffeedistributors.com/blog/coffee-history-coffee-culture/is-coffees-third-wave-sustainable
Ok, so this picture is from a third wave of coffee site -
who knew there was a third wave of coffee?
Third wave feminism was made possible by the previous two "waves" and all the people who worked so hard!  I don't remember if we used the term third wave feminism when I first started learning about it in the 1990s, but I know that by the end of the 1990s it was becoming a common place term. I was pretty confused because I tended to think of the 1960s equal rights as being both women's rights and racial equality, so I didn't understand the differences. Looking back, I can see it more clearly. So much of feminism had been defined in the past through the lens of middle and upper class white women.

So, for me, the lead-up to the third wave of feminism was about opening up and realizing the need for discussion amongst people from a variety of walks of life. A funny current example of where this third wave of feminism has brought us is that most of the people I find interesting on OK Cupid have a note on their profile that says something along the lines of, "If the majority of books on your favorites list are by white men, I'll look askance, and we might not get along."

That is where I am and have been since the 1990s. Oh, my ideas and opinions have changed and grown as I've learned more and seen more of the world, but my basic ideology of equality has remained the same. I still see the fundamental problem as -isms (racism, sexism, ageism, etc.). They are all interconnected and will remain an issue as long as our society is focused on hierarchy. It's a ladder with everybody on it, and if we're going to be higher up the ladder, we have to put people below us.

A great example of one of my own hierarchical prejudices is that I have a college degree and often find myself thinking that someone else should have worked harder to get one. This is most likely to occur when somebody says something about how "it must be nice to have so much money," gets angry at me for expecting hot water always be available in my apartment, or sends me a resume for a writing job when they can't even put a decent sentence together on a document that represents their professional abilities when trying to get a job that will involve them putting together other people's resumes.

This is a real issue that I still fight against. especially as more and more discussions happen about why expecting good grammar is classist. I've reconciled it with the fact that I do need basic grammar to enjoy a good conversation, but it certainly doesn't have to be perfect. Clarity is important, and lack of punctuation, for example, makes it very difficult for me to follow someone's train of thought. However, my work grammar is very different from my home grammar, and my blog is often filled with grammatical errors and typos. At work, if I'm reviewing someone's sample documents for a writing job I definitely expect a higher level of expertise and will look down on someone who's applying for a writing job without actually having any discernible writing abilities.

I also have to fight against other ingrained beliefs in this hierarchical system. It took me years to be comfortable around people who grew up with more money than I did. I resented their "easy" lives and bizarre ideas that high school kids shouldn't work because their job is school. I still get antsy when  people talk about how parents are "supposed" to pay for their kids to go to college and that their parents gave them $30,000 for their wedding or their grandmother took the entire extended family for a two week vacation in Europe. I become so jealous that I start looking down on them for taking advantage of what they have had all their lives and I boost myself up by telling myself that I'm better because I worked hard for what I have even if I am still paying off my college degree and can't afford to go on fancy vacations because nobody handed it to me. Blah blah blah, American dream, pulled myself up by my boot straps, yaddi yaddi yadda.

The fact is that I'm not better than any of those people. I have learned to expect certain privileges, and I have had a lot of luck in my life. I had parents who sure weren't perfect but who always, without fail, loved me. They didn't haver college diplomas, but they defined me through academic achievements. That wasn't always for the best; I still shy away from academic failure and even internet tests make me sweat if I can't get the right answer to who composed the Buffy theme song. Overall, though, it allowed me to become who I am and, apparently, to look down on folks who didn't have the same opportunities I did.

Yet I still find ways to be shocked at how some other people would apply feminism. Did you know that there is literally a Feminist Nazi movement?  I'm not talking about Rush Limbaugh's Feminazi crazy. I'm talking about female white supremacists who believe in equal rights for white women and all white people being "better" than anybody else. Needless to say, this is certainly not third wave feminism or any wave of real feminism. This is a prejudicial pile of of epic proportions. You can read about it in Lindsey Shrupp's essay "We Found Some Actual Feminazis - as in Feminist Nazis."

I don't know where feminism is going, but I know that feminist nazis aren't it. There are too many awesome people out there for us to let that happen. I am thrilled with the fourth wave of feminism and surprised that they're using the word "feminist" to define it. I'm glad that they are because the word has such a long and rich history, even though "fem" is such a small part of what we are really discussing when we think about feminism. I love the technological angle and the focus of individual self-definition, as opposed to allowing external definitions to be who we are (which was still present in the third wave of feminism and is still visible now). I also understand that the labeling of waves is in and of itself confusing. This falls under "your ideology is not my feminism, and your ideology is socially oppressive and not free from criticism."*

In the 1990s, I couldn't have imagined the current alphabet soup of terminologies (GLBTQPAI...) or how trans rights would change our ways of viewing the world and defining ourselves. With individual definitions and a strengths based approach, we are viewing people as survivors, as strong, as able to make their own decisions. Basic terminologies have changed, for example, we discuss survivors of domestic violence instead of victims of domestic abuse. Terminology does matter! That shit about sticks and stones may break my bones but words will never hurt me? It's bullshit. If someone calls you a victim enough times, it will be that many times harder for you to view yourself as something more. A rose by any other name would not smell as sweet because if I name my kid shit and always call the kid a piece of shit, they're going to feel like a piece of shit.

I didn't envision Occupy Wall Street or Black Lives Matter or so many of the amazing things that are happening around me. I also never envisioned that Planned Parenthood would be attacked or that women's basic rights would be eroding around me. I never would have guessed that someone like Bernie Sanders could be a real contender in the Democratic presidential options.  I look forward to seeing what comes next and hope like heck that it moves in a direction of equality for all!

I wanted to end this post with a photo and link to a site that sells shirts that say, "Pro Choice, Pro Feminism, Pro Unicorns," but I can't find anybody who sells them in 3x (my size), so damnit, I'm not going to link to their stores.





* This sentence is a paraphrase from a blog post I read at some point; if you know who or where it's from, please let me know, and I'll credit the original writer.

Monday, June 22, 2015

Guilty Conversations

I can stand up and discuss the need for equal rights and share articles with my friends on facebook about what needs to change in our world.  I can read books and listen to speeches and chat with like minded friends about the state of our world, but when it comes down to it, I’m not comfortable with racism.  It makes me fidgety, and while I can have “big picture” discussions, I’m not good at one-on-one conversations about it.  When I do have in depth conversations about racism and prejudice, the conversations are almost exclusively with other white folks (and, in fact, usually with other white women).

I’m embarrassed because I don’t know a lot about racism.  Oh, sure, I know the big picture concepts.  I understand how it negatively affects the world. I’m not good with the day-to-day personal life of racism. I end up comfortable and afraid to broach the topic. The majority of my friends are white women, even though I live in a heavily Armenian and Asian town.  I do discuss race in person with a few of them, and with some of my friends we have held conversations about how we’re not sure how to discuss it and then make racist jokes while singing “Everyone’s a little bit racist sometimes” because we aren’t sure how to discuss whatever the specific topic was without making racist commentary and feel better purposely making a joke that we apologize for.  Then we say, “I’d never say something like that in public,” or “You’re the only person I’d say that to.”  





Without having conversations, though, how do we find the right framework and language for the personal discussions?  We have the language and reference points for the large societal issues but not for conversations amongst ourselves, and that’s a problem.

I have been known to get into arguments with my family about race while avoiding saying anything to strangers because I have no vested interest in them.  It’s easier.  I want my family to learn and grow with me so that we can all be the best that we can be. But instead I fail and just end up creating chasms in relationships that seem impossible to breach and end up with apologies or situations where we just ignore the fight.  (Oh, and to make it clear – this is true on so many other topics when it comes to family!)


I don't have children.  I don't plan to have children, but I do read many of the parenting blog posts my friends link on Facebook.  I think about what you are possibly going through as you try to live and work and learn and grow and raise your children in a world that seems very different from the one we grew up in because we didn’t generally have these discussions at all with our parents.

I have seen so many articles about how difficult it is for Caucasian parents to explain racism and prejudice to children because many Caucasians have problems figuring out how to frame the questions and answers and ideas in a manner that won't create or expose further problems... I have the same problem myself, and I don't even have the added task of attempting to converse with children and not create another generation of folks who have the same problems and silence.

Reading books and theories from the 1970s, the ideas and concepts themselves were different.  Language and ideas have grown and changed, and I haven’t kept up with it.  I started learning and growing and understanding in my teens and twenties then just stopped because I had already read that.  I’d been there.  I’d done that.  I want someone to tell me what books I can read that can help me understand the world I live in today and not the world from two decades ago.  But I don’t because I don’t want to tell anybody that I’m embarrassed.  I don’t ask for help because I can’t admit that I don’t know how to “fix” racism even within my own personal square of the world. 

I re-post race articles on my FB or put a notification about them on my blog, but I rarely hold a discussion on them in a public forum.  I have discussions in small enclaves among other Caucasian folks I am close to.  If I decide to bring up the topic of racism and prejudice, I sometimes stutter and am just not sure how to work out what I want to say or ask without sounding like I want an African American man to explain to me racism and how I can be a part of the solution or asking an Asian woman what she wants from me because I don't want to put my discomfort onto someone else; someone whose job isn't to tell me what to think and who shouldn't have to explain things to me.

So I wanted to point out that Hillary Clinton is saying something.  She is asking us to step up and take responsibility for our own actions, to think about how we talk to those around us, how we talk to our children.  She is pointing out that what we don't say is just as important. 

I suggest that we need to not just talk to our children but to each other.  I still don’t know how, but maybe I’ll keep reading and accept the fact that I will make an ass of myself and probably make inappropriate commentary.  I don’t know what I’ll do, but what I need to not do is not try to frame today’s world in 1990 political rhetoric any longer.